Category Archives: tv

gotham-101

Fox’s Gotham must focus on corruption, not fan service

Fox’s latest foray into comics adaptations, the new television series Gotham, premiered to strong ratings this week. The series follows future Police Commissioner James Gordon in his early years on the police force of Batman’s hometown, Gotham City. The early ratings show how strong the Batman franchise is, with the pilot drawing 8 million viewers. Critics seem to enjoy the show as well, believing it could be the strongest hit of the new season.

But Gotham will only live up to the expectations if its writers quickly figure out what they want the show to be. Should it be the story of Jim Gordon and his mission to clean up the city of Gotham and its corrupt police department? Or should the show be about fan service, winking and nodding at the audience while introducing an 8-year-old Clayface?

Gotham’s first episode tried hard to be both, spending most of its first half with pointless sightings of young Catwoman, Poison Ivy, The Riddler, and The Penguin, before settling into a very strong plot in the second half hour. After getting past those useless Easter eggs, Gotham became an intriguing show, with Gordon realizing the police aren’t necessarily the good guys and coming to terms with what needs to be done to survive. Gordon ends the episode with a new mission to extricate the scum from his new home, and the audience is drawn in to join him on his futile mission, despite us knowing that Gordon will ultimately be unsuccessful. (If Gordon did succeed, there would be no need for a now-8-year-old Bruce Wayne to ever don the cape and cowl.) But the struggle to change the corrupt system from within is intriguing in itself and offers a lot of opportunities for future story lines.

Focusing the story of the first episode on the murder of Thomas and Martha Wayne was another good choice, as it reminds the viewer of the future in store for Gotham while also allowing Gordon an opportunity to utilize his detective skills. Unlike the extraneous cameos of other Batman characters, Bruce’s early meetings with Gordon are internally consistent and in step with the larger scale mythology due to their personal relationship as well as the prominence of the Wayne family name in Gotham City.

Gotham City, just as much as any of the heroes or villains, has always been its own character within the DC Universe. Gotham is almost always seen in the dark, features gothic architecture, and seems to house the worst of the worst in criminals, politicians, and police officers. Bruce Wayne is a victim of the city, having been traumatized by his parents’ senseless murder at a very young age. As Batman, Bruce sets out every night to fight an endless war on crime, supposedly hoping that his actions will eventually make his city safer. But Gotham always fights back.

Organized crime in the city is controlled by demi-warlords, with battles over turf leading to the deaths of innocent victims all the time. When Batman is able to stop the traditional criminals, he is met by more ludicrous and theatrical challengers who often show signs of poor mental health, likely a direct result of living in a corrupt city with no viable social safety net and, consequently, a complete lack of hope.

The Gotham City that existed before Batman emerged has been explored in comics for years but never as extensively as Fox’s new show promises to do. The potential is intriguing right from the start, but it appears as though the writers are short on ideas, with the first episode showing a stark reliance on characters whose relevance is almost completely dependent on the existence of Batman. Catwoman is not interesting as an 8-year-old pickpocket; she’s interesting as the bad girl who boils Batman’s blood. She is interesting in Frank Miller’s interpretation in Batman: Year One because she is the first civilian to adopt Batman’s idea of theatricality. Poison Ivy is not an intriguing character because her father probably beat her; she is an intriguing character because of her power over plants and her use of toxins to incapacitate her foes. Both characters rely heavily on their sex appeal as weapons, often catching Bruce Wayne and other opponents off guard. These characters in their prepubescence are completely useless to a show that should be about police corruption and moral ambiguity.

Gordon, however, has always been one of the most impressive characters in DC Comics, and is certainly a deserving protagonist. Gordon, created by Bill Finger and Bob Kane, was introduced in Detective Comics #27 — the same first issue as Batman himself — and has been a comic book staple ever since. In a world of vigilantes and super-powered aliens, Gordon is a workaday every man, struggling to make the streets safer. Gordon has no superpowers and, unlike Batman, is not motivated by a personal vendetta or a traumatic experience. Gordon just does the right thing because it is the right thing. He is the incorruptible man in a city that thrives on corruption.

One definition of bravery is that it is not the absence of fear, but the presence of fear and the willingness to overcome it. By that standard, Gordon is a braver man than even Bruce Wayne. Batman does not fear his own death and would unflinchingly sacrifice his life for the betterment of mankind. Gordon, however, has constructed a life and a family and does not live with a death wish like his counterpart and friend. Gordon makes mistakes, like when he cheated on his first wife, and he has suffered great tragedy, including seeing his daughter shot and crippled by The Joker. But he fights on, maintaining his moral compass and owning up to his few errors in judgment. Gordon is so compelling as a hero, in fact, that IGN voted him No. 19 in its list of the Top 100 Comic Book Heroes, placing him higher than Green Arrow, Shazam, and most X-Men.

The writers of Gotham will do well to remember the strength of their lead character and build around him instead of focusing on the exciting, theatrical villains of Batman lore before they actually become exciting, theatrical villains. The police corruption plot, unveiled 28 minutes or so into the first episode, is enough to make the series great. We don’t need to see Selina Kyle pouring milk for cats in back alleys.

portlandia-spoiler

Spoilers can be a nightmare — or a favorite pastime

Spoilers are the bane of many fans’ existence — and the lifeblood for many others. Depending on your point of view, spoilers can either ruin an epic twist in your favorite series, or tide you over through those interminable days, weeks, or months between episodes. They can detract from your enjoyment of a program or, as a recent article from Wired argues, increase it.

And they can create tense rifts between the spoilerphobes and spoilerhounds in a show’s fan base — especially as everyone’s definition for “what is a spoiler” is different, as is everyone’s idea of the timeframe for how long something remains a spoiler.

If you’re in the camp of those who either don’t care about spoilers or even actively seek them out, Netflix has a new website just for you. As for me, I do my best to avoid any and all spoilers for my favorite shows. I don’t mind vague references to things that are coming up; in fact, it’s nearly impossible to avoid those because I spend a lot of time reading entertainment news. However, I don’t like when a major plot twist or character death is given away without warning. I’ll be forever scarred by seeing a friend’s Facebook status update about the death of a certain Irish sheriff before the episode of Once Upon a Time I was missing had even finished airing.

The author of the Wired article argues that humans really don’t enjoy surprises or twists as much as we think we do, but I disagree. For me, a show is all about the journey, and every twist and surprise is an important part of that trip. I enjoy the feeling I get when a TV show takes me completely by surprise; so rarely do shows manage to accomplish it.

Agents of S.H.I.E.L.D. pulled it off last season, and I loved every minute of it. Then, the burden of spoiler-protection fell to me, as I had to go all summer without revealing (here comes that spoiler!) Agent Ward’s betrayal of S.H.I.E.L.D. to certain members of my family because they hadn’t finished the season. I recently re-watched that first season with a friend and, even though I enjoyed it just as much the second time around, I still appreciate the thrill I got from being surprised the first time. It just wouldn’t have been the same had I known what to expect.

Yes, not knowing what’s around the corner is naturally uncomfortable for a species built to survive. Being in the dark can be nerve-wracking at times, but when it comes to being entertained, I love that tension and suspense. I learned that lesson 15 years ago when I was accidentally spoiled on the ending of The Sixth Sense just days after it came out in theaters. I still lament the fact that I’ll never be able to see that film without knowing about the twist; I feel so deprived of that shock. I think that’s the moment when I really began avoiding spoilers as much as possible.

Whether you avoid spoilers or not, it’s important to try to at least have respect for any member of your fandom who has different views on the subject. But what constitutes a spoiler?

With such variation in definitions from person to person, we may as well turn to the crowdsourced Urban Dictionary, where the top definition of “spoiler” is: “When someone reveals a previously unknown aspect of something which you likely would have rather learned on your own.” By this definition, almost anything about a show you haven’t seen yet would qualify as a spoiler. I prefer to know as little information as possible about an episode that hasn’t aired yet, but there are certain things I don’t consider spoilers: previews for a new episode, casting announcements, and other promotional and logistical items. More specific details about an episode, such as whether someone dies or turns out to be a double agent, for example, qualify as spoilers in my book.

Of course, not everyone agrees with where I draw the line. I know fans who won’t even watch previews for upcoming episodes because they don’t want to know anything before they see the episode. Some show runners even agree with this harsh standard; Matthew Weiner is known for supplying AMC with such vague and disjointed episode previews for Mad Men that no one can glean any worthwhile information from that credits-sharing sequence. But it’s good to remember that not everyone is this strict. With so much variance, when you do accidentally come across spoilers, perhaps whoever posted the information did not consider their comment to be a spoiler.

One thing to keep in mind if you’re trying to avoid spoilers is that social media is a virtual minefield of spoilers. If you’re not going to watch the latest episode of The Walking Dead live but feel the need to check your Twitter feed, don’t be surprised if you glimpse something you’d rather not see.

If I know I’m going to be missing an episode of a show that I definitely wouldn’t want to find spoilers for, I avoid social media as much as possible. I even limit my online exposure during the few hours between the time Doctor Who airs in the United Kingdom and when I can watch it here in the United States.

On the flip side, if you know you have followers or friends who are behind, it’s only polite to avoid posting explicit spoilers. I know this is hard. I often tweet while I’m watching television shows, but I try to avoid posting anything too detailed about what is happening. Sometimes, vague tweets can be even more fun.

But the question becomes: at what point is a spoiler no longer a spoiler? By now, if you don’t know that Darth Vader is Luke’s father or that Dumbledore doesn’t make it out of Hogwarts alive, you’re either really out of touch or really good at avoiding spoilers. There are just some things that have become a part of pop culture and there’s no way to avoid knowing how they end. I just watched Psycho for the first time a few years ago, but I’ve known about the ending for as long as I can remember. In that case, knowing how the movie ended didn’t at all lessen my enjoyment of the film.

I hope the same will hold true for a recently completed TV series. I plan to watch all of Breaking Bad someday soon and am trying to avoid spoilers, but I know I can’t expect everyone around me to refrain from posting them. In fact, I have already been partially spoiled as to the end of the series — but that’s the price I pay for not watching the series when it was originally airing. However, others may be irate if you were to spoil the end of the series for them.

My general rule of thumb is to give a television show at least 24 hours before I post anything I would consider a spoiler (unless I have friends who I know haven’t seen the episode and won’t want to be spoiled). It frustrates me when people post about big twists before the episode has even ended — at the very least, you should wait three hours until the West Coast has gotten to see the episode. After 24 hours, if you still haven’t watched the episode, you better just be good at avoiding spoilers, because it’s open season, in my opinion.

It’s a little different for books or movies. With movies, I try to wait at least a week or two after their release, and with books, at least a month. Usually, by then, those who are most interested have already seen the movie or read the book.

That doesn’t mean you should intentionally spoil somebody. If your friend tells you they’re marathoning Lost for the first time, don’t go and tell them how the series ends. Have some respect and let them experience the show for themselves. If anyone asks you not to spoil something specific, be it a book, movie, or TV series, common courtesy says you just don’t do it.

If you don’t think you can handle not posting about what you’ve seen or read, find a discussion board or someplace dedicated to spoilers where you can talk about it. There are plenty of places online where you spoiler fans are welcome.

There really is no common ground where spoilers are concerned, but we can all try to respect our fellow fans when it comes to spoilers.

And whatever you do, please don’t tell me how Breaking Bad ends. I already know more than I want to.

constantine

Fall changes have potential to bring new TV faves

Fall doesn’t officially start until Tuesday, but the cooler temperatures in my part of the country over the past week prove that the change of seasons is definitely upon us. As I pointed out last week, the arrival of fall also means the arrival of fall television. Last week, I shared some of the returning shows I was happiest to have back on my screen. This week, I’ll take a look at the new series I’m looking forward to checking out.

I don’t tend to watch a lot of sitcoms as they air live. The Big Bang Theory and How I Met Your Mother were exceptions to that rule, and for each of them, I came in after several seasons had already aired. I’m a fan of New Girl, though I’m usually a season behind and watching on Netflix. Last season, I enjoyed The Crazy Ones, then was disappointed when the series was canceled and even more heartbroken when we lost Robin Williams last month.

This year, I am planning to give Selfie on ABC a chance — despite its annoying pop culture title. I have to admit, if the series wasn’t starring Karen Gillan and John Cho, I probably wouldn’t even consider watching … although the idea that it’s loosely based on My Fair Lady also has me intrigued. I loved Gillan as Amy Pond in Doctor Who, but she really impressed me this summer as Nebula in Guardians of the Galaxy. I can’t wait to see how she does in an American sitcom. Early reviews for the series have been really positive, so this may be a case of “don’t judge a series by its title.”

Speaking of former Doctor Who stars, the Tenth Doctor himself will be starring in Gracepoint on Fox this fall. Gracepoint is a 10-episode television “event” based on the British series Broadchurch. David Tennant will be reprising his role from the original series, this time with an American accent. The show centers on the investigation into the murder of a young child in a small seaside town.

Broadchurch was absolutely fantastic, and if you enjoy suspenseful crime drama, I highly recommend it. The cast and the writing were brilliant; it was easily one of the best series I watched last year. At first, I was disappointed to hear that Fox was making its own version of the series, and I was determined not to watch: there is no way they could even come close to the quality of its predecessor. But the casting of Tennant has made me curious, and I’ll willingly watch anything in which he appears.

According to Fox, the story will not play out exactly as the mystery in Broadchurch did. The writers have apparently changed the ending so fans of the original won’t know what’s going to happen. However, the trailers I’ve seen for the show so far make it look like the series was shot matching the original, frame by frame. Changes must have been made, though, to accommodate the fact that the American version is 10 episodes long versus the eight episodes of the British series. Hopefully, those changes do not lessen the suspense or drama that was so effective in the original series.

While Marvel has proved that it can easily dominate the box office, DC has seen a lot of success on the small screen over the years. This fall, NBC, the CW, and Fox will all premiere new series based on DC comics staples.

There has been a lot of hype and anticipation for Fox’s Gotham, which tells the story of James Gordon, the future police commissioner, prior to the existence of Batman. The series will also provide origin stories for many members of The Rogues Gallery. So great is the excitement for this series that Netflix has already acquired the exclusive rights to stream it after the episodes’ first runs. I tend to be skeptical of any genre show that Fox airs — not because I don’t believe it will be good, but because even if it is, there’s a high chance of Fox pulling the plug without really giving it a chance. The success of Sleepy Hollow last year, though, has given me some measure of hope.

Gotham will bring a talented cast into our living rooms. I’m particularly excited about Donal Logue playing Gordon’s partner. Logue has the ability to pull of great comedy or serious drama, and I’ve really enjoyed every performance of his that I’ve seen. I wasn’t a fan of The O.C. or Southland, so I know nothing of Ben McKenzie, who will be playing Gordon, other than that he’s more clean-cut than I was expecting. I’m really curious to see what he’s like. Lastly, a bit of trivia for the Doctor Who fans: Alfred, the butler for the Wayne family, will be played by actor Sean Pertwee, the son of the Third Doctor, Jon Pertwee.

Constantine is probably the series I know the least about but am still looking forward to watching. I’m not very familiar with the source character, beyond his appearances in the The Sandman comics and the Keanu Reeves film (or the knowledge that he inspired the look for Supernatural‘s Castiel), but I’m still intrigued by this series. Series star Matt Ryan certainly appears to have the look and attitude of John Constantine.

I haven’t heard much about this series over the summer, aside from the news that Lucy Griffiths‘ character, one of the main characters in the pilot, had been written out for creative reasons. I was a little disappointed by this news, as I’ve been a fan of Griffiths since she played Marian on BBC’s Robin Hood. Since I haven’t heard as much hype about Constantine as some of the other series on this list, my expectations for it are not as high. Of course, the lack of buzz also makes me a little more concerned about its fate at the network. (NBC doesn’t have a much better reputation than Fox when it comes to giving series a chance.) I also have a feeling my lack of knowledge about the comics will work in my favor, as I won’t be comparing it to the comics or criticizing certain creative decisions.

The new series I’m most excited about this fall is probably The Flash. I wasn’t sure about casting Grant Gustin as Barry Allen at first, but I could have been a little biased by his appearance on Glee. However, I really enjoyed his two-episode appearance on Arrow last season, and I am now looking forward to seeing what the show looks like. I’m also excited that it appears The Flash and Arrow will remain closely connected, as Stephen Amell has already confirmed his appearance in the pilot episode, and a crossover is set for episode 8 of each show’s upcoming season.

I’m also a fan of the rest of the cast, which includes Tom Cavanaugh, Jesse L. Martin, and the former Barry Allen himself, John Wesley Ship, as Barry’s father. Recurring cast members will include Robbie Amell, Stephen’s cousin and the star of last seasons ill-fated The Tomorrow People, and Prison Break‘s Wentworth Miller. The previews for the series so far have looked great, and I can’t wait for it to premiere. I just hope it doesn’t take as long to draw me in as Arrow did.

There are all the new series I’m most excited about seeing premiere in the next few weeks. What new shows are you looking forward to? Are there any here I forgot that you think are worth a mention (or worth checking out)? Leave your thoughts in the comments!

once-frozen

Favorite shows return to lineup in new fall TV season

If you are a Binge Watcher and are lagging behind on Sleepy Hollow, The Vampire Diaries, Arrow, Supernatural, Once Upon a Time, or Marvel’s Agents of S.H.I.E.L.D., you should probably skip this season preview until you’re all caught up.

It’s that time of year again. The weather is turning colder, days are getting shorter, and pumpkin spiced everything is available anywhere you go. This is my favorite season — the time of year for hoodies or warm sweaters, bonfires, and hot apple cider.

It is also when fan*s start counting down to the start of the fall television season. In the next two weeks, our favorites will return and an interesting new lineup will begin. I thought I would take some time this week to look at the returning shows I’m most looking forward to, then next week discuss some of the new shows I’m planning to check out.

As you know if you’ve been reading this column, I am a huge fan of television, and I watch quite a wide range of shows. There are some that I continue to watch simply out of habit or because other members of my household still enjoy them: NCIS, Hawaii Five-O, Blue Bloods, etc. I like the characters and continue to watch, though I’m not as invested in those shows as I am in some others. The majority of my favorite shows have some sort of science-fiction or fantasy aspect to them, but there are a few straight dramas I enjoy. (Not coincidentally, most of them star actors I first discovered on genre shows.) Bones and Castle are probably my favorite crime dramas currently on television.

There are quite a few more genre shows that I’m excited about, starting with Sleepy Hollow. When I added this show to my to-watch list last fall, I thought it looked interesting, but I really didn’t know how the premise was going to hold up. Based on prior experiences with genre TV on Fox, I also didn’t have a lot of hope for it to stick around. Then the show surprised everyone with the quality of the scripts and a brilliant cast. I was pretty sure I would like it, but I never expected it to receive the response it did. Fox rarely makes decisions I agree with when it comes to programming, but I think it made a good choice in keeping the first season short; one thing I’ve learned from British television is that shorter seasons can really add to the quality of a season since writers don’t have to spread out the storyline so far and fill in the gaps.

The first season finale reveal that sin-eater Henry Parrish was not only Ichabod’s son but also one of the Four Horsemen took me completely by surprise, which is something few shows manage to accomplish. With Katrina now in the present and Abbie stuck in limbo, I am anxious to see how they resolve the cliffhanger from season 1 and carry on the second season. I’m also extremely excited about John Noble being added as a regular this year. He is an incredible actor, and the fact that he was never nominated for an Emmy for Fringe is nothing short of criminal.

I’m also looking forward to the return of my CW shows — Arrow and Supernatural much more so than The Vampire Diaries and The Originals. The first season of The Originals was vastly more compelling than anything that’s happened on The Vampire Diaries in the last couple years, though I am very excited that Alaric is returning as a VD regular; I’ve really missed Matthew Davis on the show and have been hoping for his return ever since the CW cancelled Cult (which I just could not get into).

Arrow really stepped up its game last season, especially in the episodes leading up to the finale. I’m a little disappointed that the end of the Slade storyline means we likely won’t see more of Manu Bennett any time soon — and he’ll be unrecognizable in The Hobbit: The Battle of Five Armies. Still, I’m curious about the direction they’re headed this season, as it seems the flashbacks are moving off of the island. It will also be interesting to see Roy make the transition into a regular member of Team Arrow as he dons the Arsenal costume. I only wish the writers would do something about Laurel. I don’t know whether it’s the writing or Katie Cassidy herself, but I struggle with the fact that I couldn’t care less about her character, which is difficult when I love everything else about the show.

Supernatural will be starting its 10th season this fall, which seems like a miracle to those of us who were waiting on pins and needles back in 2006 to see if it would even get a second run. The show kind of lost its way in seasons 6 and 7 after creator Eric Kripke stepped back from running the show. However, another change in leadership after season 7 has set it back on track, with seasons 8 and 9 being a huge improvement on the previous two.

This season, Supernatural is adding a fourth season regular for the first time, as Mark Sheppard joins the cast. Sheppard’s Crowley is one of those villains everyone loves to hate, and Sheppard himself is well-loved in the genre community. When last we looked in on the Winchester brothers, Sam was mourning and Dean was resurrected as a demon. I have no idea what this coming season has in store for us — aside from the rumors of a “musical” 200th episode — but I’m hoping they let the demon Dean storyline play out. I’m really curious to see what Dean is like as a demon and feel like this is a storyline that would feel rushed if they try to wrap it up and make him human again within the first couple episodes of the season.

One of the returning shows I’m possibly most excited about is Once Upon a Time. When the season ended with a glimpse of Elsa from Frozen, I wasn’t sure what to think. At first, I was a little disappointed because Frozen, though a lovely movie, is everywhere you look, and this felt like the writers were just jumping on the bandwagon. However, I’ve since read numerous interviews in which the creators have stated that Disney had absolutely nothing to do with this decision; the show runners are fans of Frozen and thought the characters would fit well into the series. I’m now willing to give them the benefit of the doubt and see how the Frozen storyline turns out.

Aside from Frozen, I’m really looking forward to seeing all my favorite Once Upon a Time characters again. I am still a little sad they killed Neal last year, but Hook and Emma have such great chemistry, I can’t wait to see what’s next. Then there is the question of how Regina will react now that Robin Hood’s wife is alive and in Storybrooke. Regina is such an easy character to hate, but in so many ways, her character’s arc is the most interesting. I just hope she doesn’t fall back to season 1 Regina. Lastly, I’m really excited about Once Upon a Time in Wonderland‘s Michael Socha joining the cast as a series regular. Socha’s Knave of Hearts was by far the best character of the spin-off series, and the reveal that he’s also Will Scarlet means he has a lot of history with Robin Hood and should fit in well with the Storybrooke residents.

The other returning show I’m most excited about would, of course, be Marvel’s Agents of S.H.I.E.L.D. The show had such a slow start, but it hit its stride around episode 6, then really went into high gear with the release of Captain America: The Winter Soldier. The end of the season left Coulson tasked with picking up the pieces of the shattered S.H.I.E.L.D. after Director Fury handed over the reigns. I cannot wait to see where the show goes from here. From the casting announcements I’ve been hearing, we’ll be seeing a lot more Marvel characters this season and getting some glimpses of Agent Carter in flashbacks — possibly as a sneak peak of what to expect from the Agent Carter series set to premiere mid-season.

S.H.I.E.L.D.’s second year will also be picking up with a team that is already unified and already knows each other, so they can jump right into the mission. I’m curious to see what role Agent Grant Ward will be playing now that we know he’s a Hydra agent. Will his character have a redemption arc? Is he capable (or deserving) of redemption? I can’t wait to find out.

These are just some of the shows I’m looking forward to having return in a few weeks. I also can’t wait for the new seasons of The Walking Dead and Grimm, plus Haven‘s final, double-sized season begins tonight.

What returning shows are you looking forward to? Share them in the comments! And tune in next week when I share which new series I’m most interested in checking out.

doctor-12-capaldi

Capaldi shines as 12th Doctor, creates dark first impression

Earlier this week, a friend of mine shared on Facebook a link to a cartoon that perfectly sums up what conversations between Doctor Who fans have been like ever since the arrival of the Twelfth Doctor on Saturday night. When it comes to the British sci-fi show, fans are passionate about the cast, the characters, and the writing, and they are not afraid to voice their opinions. Today, I thought I’d share some of my first impressions of the Twelfth Doctor and his premiere episode, “Deep Breath.”

I loved “Deep Breath” when I was watching it for the first time Saturday. Peter Capaldi won me over almost immediately, which is probably the fastest I’ve accepted a new Doctor. From the moment he peeked out of the TARDIS and told Strax to “shush,” I knew I was going to enjoy this Doctor. When I watched it again Monday night at a movie theater, I found I still enjoyed it, but it wasn’t as engaging on repeated viewings as some episodes have been, particularly the recent 50th anniversary special, “The Day of the Doctor,” which I also saw in a theater. However, I still enjoyed the episode overall, especially Capaldi’s performance.

One of the things I really liked about the way this episode was written was how the Doctor’s companion, Clara, was almost a surrogate for the audience member. In so many ways, she voiced all the doubts a fan has ever had about a Doctor’s regeneration throughout the episode: Why was he old? Why couldn’t he just change back? Do we still know who the Doctor is? Clara had to walk the same path from surprise, denial, then loss, to eventual acceptance right along with the fans.

One thing I particularly liked about Clara in this episode was how, even though it appeared as though the Doctor had completely deserted her when she needed him the most, she still held out her hand, confident he would be there. She knew some things about the Doctor would never change.

I have read a lot of negative feedback this week about Clara’s reaction to the Doctor’s regeneration. She knew it was coming, she knows the Doctor has already had many faces — has, in fact, seen all of them prior to the Twelfth Doctor — so why is she so disturbed by this regeneration? I think, for the most part, it comes down to the difference between knowing something and experiencing it. Fans all know the Doctor regenerates, but that doesn’t always make it easier for us to accept a new actor in the role.

Then there was the added complication of this new Doctor being somewhat addled at first. He didn’t seem to know how to fly the TARDIS and evidently managed to get them swallowed by a Tyrannosaurus rex. After spending so much time with a man that always seemed so in control of the situation, a man she could trust to lead her, it must have been extremely disconcerting for Clara to not have any idea what the Doctor was going to do next.

Clara also may not have fully understood just how much the Doctor’s personality can change from one regeneration to another. Her only experiences have been with the War Doctor, Ten, and Eleven. Ten and Eleven have a lot in common, plus the War Doctor always held himself together. So to see the Doctor suddenly so confused and unpredictable really couldn’t have helped Clara with the transition.

As for Capaldi, I thought he was brilliant in the role. He really felt like the Doctor right from the beginning, even if that Doctor was somewhat uncharacteristically confused. I had heard so many rumors about how much darker this Doctor would be — and we’ll get to that in a minute — that I was concerned he would not be a remotely likable person in this incarnation, but as he stood there in the end, begging Clara to just see him, my heart broke for him, and I couldn’t help but love him.

I was also impressed once again by how wonderful an actor Capaldi truly is. I had already known this, of course, but it really stood out Saturday night. Over the past couple months, I have been watching The Musketeers on BBC America, in which Capaldi plays Cardinal Richelieu, who, naturally, is not a likable character. I was afraid this would cloud my perception of him as the Doctor. However, I didn’t think of Richelieu once while I was watching “Deep Breath” — nor did I find myself comparing him with John Frobisher, another rather unlikable character from the Doctor Who spin-off Torchwood. Capaldi’s acting range and ability drew me in and made me completely forget about any other role I’ve seen him in. (And before anyone asks: no, I haven’t seen him as Malcolm Tucker, but I plan to as soon as I can find a way to view The Thick of It.)

I really enjoyed all the subtle references to previous Doctors, from the allusion to a long scarf to the Doctor mentioning that he sometimes misses Amy when Clara’s legs couldn’t reach the sonic screwdriver. I also liked the reference to the “round things” in the TARDIS — a nice callback not only to an earlier TARDIS, but to a similar comment made in “The Day of the Doctor” last year. There was also a slightly more obvious tie-in between this episode and the Tenth Doctor episode “The Girl in the Fireplace,” as these droids’ ship is the sister ship of the SS Madame de Pompadour featured in that earlier adventure.

Probably my favorite scene of “Deep Breath” was near the end, when Clara receives a phone call from the Eleventh Doctor, placed by him just before he regenerated. The call helps Clara to finally say goodbye and have closure, and I think it did the same for many fans. It was nice to see Matt Smith as the Doctor one last time.

Then, as I mentioned above, the dialogue between the Twelfth Doctor after the phone call and Clara’s final acceptance of him as the Doctor was very well done. My heart broke for this Doctor, who just wanted to be recognized and accepted by Clara. The vulnerability of the Doctor in that scene pretty much cemented my opinion of him: Capaldi is going to be great.

The one concern I have as this season continues is just how dark the Doctor will be. We’ve already had the suggestion that he may have pushed the half-faced man out of the escape pod — and that was a rather ominous look they showed on his face afterward. It is evident that the rumors of this Doctor being darker are true, but the question is just how much darker is he? I’m hoping not too dark, as the Doctor is supposed to be a good person.

The other questions this episode left us with are: who is Missy, and what is this place she referred to as Heaven? I’ve heard many theories about Missy’s identity, ranging from the Master to the Rani to an earlier incarnation of River Song to Romana or even, possibly, a dark Clara who merged with the Great Intelligence after splitting off in the Doctor’s time stream. All these theories seem interesting, and I’m not sure which would be most plausible. I would love if Missy were some character from the Doctor’s past that we have not yet met in the new series; the Master would also be an interesting option.

One thing I do know is that “Heaven” is also the same garden Amy was trapped in when she was quarantined in “The Girl Who Waited.” If this were any other series, I could say that was just a coincidence and a reused set piece, but given that Steven Moffat wrote this episode, I’m having trouble believing that.

Overall, I thought this episode was enjoyable and a great introduction to the new Doctor. I can’t wait to see what the interaction between the Doctor and Clara will be like moving forward, and how the dynamic between them changes. I have a feeling Clara will have to keep a closer eye on this Doctor, as well as watch out for herself more often than she is accustomed to.

What are your thoughts on the Twelfth Doctor?

outlander103

Outlander: Claire heals, hopes to return home

Last week, the Starz adaptation of Outlander made some creative choices that separated it from the books upon which it is based — and I, for one, became concerned. In the series’ third episode, “The Way Out,” additional small changes were evident, but they served as effective tools to help with the transition from the written word to the small screen.

The episode opens with a flashback in which Claire Beauchamp, who has traveled through time to 18th-century Scotland, is back in her own world, bidding farewell to her husband Frank as she embarks on a train to the front lines to serve as a combat nurse in World War II. This scene emphasizes that Claire’s independent nature, illustrated so far during her time in and around the ancient Castle Leoch, is a characteristic of her 20th-century self as well: she is unwilling to play the role of the stereotypical housewife. Frank asks her to reconsider joining the war effort, but Claire insists on being of service. With resignation, Frank laments, “Woe betide the man who stands between you and what you set your mind upon…”

Claire finds herself in her room at Castle Leoch. Mrs. Fitz is fussing over Claire when Claire turns to tell her that she has fallen through time at Craigh na Dun, the circle of stones near Inverness. Mrs. Fitz clearly is afraid when Claire says that she is from the future and that her husband, who everyone thinks is dead, actually hasn’t been born yet. Claire reveals she is from 1945 and has unwittingly found herself in 1743. Claire isn’t sure if she can even go back to her own time. Claire pleads for Mrs. Fitz to help her get back to the stones. Mrs. Fitz slaps her in the face and accuses her of witchcraft. At this point, I am seething, as nothing remotely similar to this scenario takes place in the book.

Seconds later, however, I am relieved to find that this scene was imagined by Claire. As far as this interaction strays from the book, it does serve an important purpose here. The Highland people of the 18th century were (and, to some degree, still are) a superstitious bunch. Their folklore is filled with fairies, spirits, witchcraft, and the constant need to defend oneself against Satan’s ever-present seduction. This background may not be clear to someone not already familiar with Scottish history or anyone who has yet to read the novel. The beliefs of the locals are pivotal to the storyline, and this daydream helps to establish the backdrop for future events.

Mrs. Fitz reveals that The Gathering is coming. The Gathering is an event at which all of the men living on the land of Clan MacKenzie come and swear allegiance to their laird. Claire feels this might be an opportunity to get the Clan’s leader, Colum, to trust her — by “physicking” the ill and earning her freedom. She sets about organizing the medical suite unknowingly left to her by the late Davey Beaton, the castle’s previous healer. Her healing skills are becoming a respected and much-sought asset.

It is revealed to Claire that one of the maids’ sons has died. Claire is told that the child, young Lindsey MacNeill, succumbed the previous night. When Claire inquires as to why she wasn’t called upon, Mrs. Fitz tells her that the boy died of nothing mere mortals could cure. The boy, she says, has died because he visited “The Black Kirk,” the ruins of an old Benedictine monastery. She, as well as everyone else in the area, believes he was taken by evil spirits who dwell in the stony rubble.

Claire, of course, believes none of this but says nothing. She is then called to Colum’s rooms, where he is found having a hilarious conversation with a tailor about the length of his coat. Colum is offended that the tailor is attempting to measure Colum for a frock coat considerably longer than the standard knee-length. The tailor assumed that Colum wanted his deformed legs covered, but clearly Colum does not.

Colum requests from the new healer a massage for his pain, as Beaton used to do. He and Claire get into a conversation about the cause of Lindsey’s death; Claire is vague about her belief that Lindsey was killed by demons. Colum says, “What, you don’t have demons in Oxfordshire, Mistress?” Claire pauses and returns with, “Well, we do … but we call them Scots.” Colum appreciates her humor and invites her as his personal guest to hear a famous Welsh bard, Gwyllyn, perform in The Hall that night.

At The Hall, Claire formally introduces herself to Mrs. Fitz’s granddaughter, Laoghaire MacKenzie. The girl obviously admires Jamie, the young man who saved her from punishment in the previous episode. Laoghaire admits that, while she likes Jamie, he does not return her affection. Claire promises to steer Jamie in her direction. However, her attempt is unsuccessful. Several times, Claire tries to encourage Jamie to attend to Laoghaire, but he is just shy of rude to her in order to converse directly with Claire.

Jamie and Claire discuss the talents of the bard, which are extraordinary. This musician, played by renowned medieval Gaelic singer and poet Gillebride MacMillan, is a marvel. The snippets of his performances alone make Outlander a must-see: the gorgeous vocals, rich in emotion and depth, further complement the already glorious set designs of this series.

Jamie notices that Claire has been imbibing Colum’s Rhenish wine. He asks her to attend to his bandages, although this is just an excuse to escort her safely from The Hall. Sparks fly when Claire and Jamie are alone in her surgery. The chemistry portrayed by the leads is fantastic. This is one thing that makes this adaptation successful. The almost karmic relationship between Jamie and Claire, established from the first book, is a key element in the entire Outlander series.

On a visit to the castle’s herb garden, Claire meets Geillis Duncan, who tells her that Mrs. Fitz’s nephew, Thomas Baxter, is taken with the same illness that killed the boy’s friend Lindsey. Geillis further informs Claire that the local priest, Father Bain, is going to exorcise the boy. Geillis warns Claire to stay away, for fear that she will be associated with evil spirits. Claire goes anyway, much to the consternation of her guard, and encounters the strident, almost psychotic, Catholic priest. He undertakes an exorcism, while Claire, realizing the boy has been poisoned by an unknown source, stands by helplessly.

A parallel storyline emerges here, with Claire recognizing her attraction to Jamie and witnessing Jamie and Laoghaire kissing quite passionately in an alcove. Claire teases Jamie about it at dinner, but one of the men warns Claire that if Colum or Laoghaire’s father hears of it, Jamie could get more than a beating — he could get a wife, “And that’s not the wife he should have …”

A happy turn of events has Claire being escorted to Cranesmuir, a village near the castle, to visit Geillis, the procurator fiscal’s wife. The Clan’s military leader, Dougal, suggests that Claire might stock her medical shelves in preparation for The Gathering. Claire is quite shocked to see that, as attractive and charming as Geillis is, her husband, the Fiscal, is much older, quite unattractive, and in ill health.

When a boy in the town confesses to stealing a loaf of bread, Geillis tells Claire that the boy will lose his hand. Claire is horrified and asks if the sentence is necessary. Her new friend asks probing questions, such as, “Do they not have that in Oxfordshire, then?” However, to appease her friend, Geillis, in a quite bewitching fashion, convinces her husband, whose job it is to settle disputes and determine punishments, to be lenient. The boy gets an hour in the pillory with one ear nailed. Claire again cannot believe that this is considered leniency, and Geillis continues her questions, making Claire worry that Geillis somehow knows that Claire is from a different time.

Claire is able to avoid further explanation when Jamie comes to escort her back to the castle. Before they go, Claire asks if Jamie can do something to help the boy, whose ear has been nailed to the pillory all day. He agrees, and Claire creates a diversion while Jamie pulls the nail, which saves the boy from having to tear himself loose.

Reminded of the plight of the violently ill Thomas Baxter, Claire asks Jamie if he can take her to The Black Kirk. Here, she discovers that a plant that everyone takes for wood garlic is, in fact, a very similar-looking — and deadly poisonous — lily-of-the-valley. This plant is commonly eaten by boys who visit the Kirk as a sign of their bravery. Claire knows the cure and, despite the angry and threatening protestations of Father Bain, gives the boy an anecdote. Soon after, the boy is cured. Instead of being delighted, Father Bain is humiliated and threatens Claire that “God will have the last word. I promise you that.”

The episode ends with another performance by Gwyllyn the Bard. This time, Claire is treated — by Jamie — to a translation of the Welsh lyrics. The song, it turns out, is about a woman who touched a stone at a fairy ring near the celebration of Samhain and was transported to another time. She made a life for herself in that other time, finding friends and lovers. But she longed for her home and the man she had left behind, and at another time near Samhain, she returned to the stone circle, touched the stone, and was transported once again to her own time. This story echoes Claire’s own journey through the stones, which also took place at a stone circle near the time of Samhain. She decides a return to 1945 — and her dear Frank — is possible, and she determines to find a way back.

No gratuitous nudity distracted from the storyline in this episode. While it varied a bit from the novel — for instance, the poisoning of the boys at The Black Kirk didn’t happen in the book — the changes were necessary to translate the plot to screen and to provide a platform for the story’s progression.

korra-s3f

Depth of characters drives strong third Korra season

The Legend of Korra’s third season has ended, and fans were treated to another incredible epic. With its latest season, The Legend of Korra proved that strong and diverse characters with powerful backstories and interesting emotional arcs can add immeasurable depth and interest to any series.

Korra’s predecessor, Avatar: The Last Airbender, saw many characters evolve across its three seasons, and Korra inherited that world with all of its implications. In Korra’s season 3, that allowed viewers to rejoin the life of Zuko, now an old man, to see how his life changed since becoming friends with Avatar Aang. But it was not the first time the series used historical continuity to build incredible characters for the world of Korra.

In Korra’s first episode, we are introduced to Tenzin, who, as the son of Avatar Aang and the water bender Katara, has the weight of the world on his shoulders. His family is the last group from the Air Nation, and we can see how Tenzin struggles with the responsibility of being the sole inheritor of a culture on the verge of extinction.

Tenzin spends the first two seasons struggling with being the son of the last Avatar. By definition, he is incapable of measuring up to the legacy of his father, whose statue stands as a beacon of hope in the waters between the Air Temple and Republic City. Tenzin literally lives in his father’s shadow and often makes decisions with his father in mind. At the same time, Tenzin is a father himself, raising four young children, fully aware that they will one day inherit his burdens.

Tenzin’s role as father is fitting, as he is the audience’s closest link to Aang and the previous generation of the show’s heroes. But for so long, Tenzin is defined and consumed only by his father’s legacy. Tenzin reaches a low point when his spiritual connections are shown to not be as strong as his own daughter’s. Tenzin beats himself up, feeling that he has let his father down, until his brother Bumi and sister Kya remind him that, while they are all Aang’s children, each one of them is also an individual. Tenzin finally realizes his value as Tenzin, the father and the mentor, and not merely the son of Aang.

Tenzin’s evolution and relationship with Korra provide some of the series’ most emotionally powerful moments. At first, Tenzin is the stuffy authority who stands in Korra’s way as she tries to live her life. But by the end of season 2, we see how much their relationship has grown into one of mutual respect and familial love. Korra makes Tenzin’s goals her own and takes it as her duty to help rebuild the Air Nation, which, after being wiped out by the Fire Nation over 100 years ago, finally has a chance to be resurrected at the beginning of season 3.

After Korra’s actions open the portals to the Spirit Dimension, the world around the Avatar begins to change drastically. Part of that change is the resurgence of air benders across the globe. Korra and Tenzin seize the moment to reestablish the Air Nation. Tenzin realizes the incredible significance as he finally has the opportunity to fulfill his father’s dreams while also creating his own legacy.

Tenzin’s strength as a leader is visible through the growth of his daughter, Jinora. Jinora started the show as a seemingly minor character, though her potential was always evident. Instead of leaving her character’s development to the imagination, the writers chose to craft an impressive story arc for her, culminating in the final scene of Korra’s third season.

Jinora shows an incredible love for history, philosophy, legends, and everything involving the Avatar and the Air Nation. It is evident from the beginning that she hopes to inherit the leadership of the Nation from her father, and with season 3, Jinora proves that she is resourceful, intelligent, and powerful. Jinora’s connection to the Spirit World gives her a power that is out of the grasp of even the Avatar, as she is able to project her consciousness across large distances. By season 3’s final scene, it is evident that Jinora has become a leader, reaching a new high, just as Korra reaches her new low.

Having two incredibly powerful woman characters would be impressive enough for any show, but The Legend of Korra goes above and beyond in showcasing powerful women. Asami, originally Korra’s rival for the affections of a boy, came into her own in the course of the show and became defined by much more than just her relationship with a boy. Asami, the head of Future Industries at a young age, stepped up in the first season as a hero, defending Team Avatar against her own father, the corrupt industrialist who was supporting the Equalists. Though she is not a bender, Asami proves herself more than capable as a fighter, utilizing her company’s technology as personal weapons and her own martial arts training to help Korra take down the leaders of the Red Lotus.

The Red Lotus, newly introduced in season 3, are four very powerful anarchist benders who seek to destroy the social order. Believing kings and presidents to be antithetical to human nature, the Red Lotus puts its philosophy into action, even succeeding in killing a world leader. Adding to the depth of these antagonists is the fact that many of the world’s leaders show themselves to be incompetent and possibly dangerous. The audience is better able to understand the characters’ motivations because there is an element of truth to what they say. Still, their actions cross a line, especially as they threaten the lives of the new members of the Air Nation.

The Red Lotus proves their might throughout the season by getting into incredible battles with characters whom the fans know are great fighters. The anarchists are able to take down all three of Aang’s children in a fair fight, establishing their credibility as a force to be reckoned with. Their dominance is then used to great effect to establish the strength of Bolin and Mako, Korra’s best friends who have to step up to the challenge of the Red Lotus warriors.

Bolin and Mako have been part of what makes Korra a great series since the beginning. The brothers of mixed nationality have a strong relationship, which we see throughout the series. Bolin, the earth bender, was always the funnier character, while Mako, the fire bender, was much more serious. The two brothers come from the streets of Republic City, where their parents were murdered, and they had to work for criminals just to survive.

Bolin and Mako are the peasants who dine with kings as they join Korra to help save the world. Mako, a detective for the police force, still mourns the death of his parents and does the best he can to be there for his brother. His growth as an independent hero continues to shine through in season 3 as his detective skills often lead the group in the right direction. But it is his emotional connection with his brother that really shines through in in the most recent season.

Bolin was always the comic relief character, and in that role has added much to the show. However, Bolin was starting to feel static by the end of Korra’s second season, which made his growth in season 3 that much more rewarding. We find out in season 3 that Bolin doesn’t have a lot of confidence in himself, which makes a lot of sense, given his brother’s abilities. Bolin tries to learn metal bending, which is a skill that very few earth benders are able to master. Bolin is shown up immediately by Korra, who masters the skill quickly. The writers play with this development throughout the season, making you believe Bolin is about to step up before ultimately failing, until the end of the season when Bolin, the perpetual comic relief character, saves everybody by proving himself in another way.

Bolin and Mako’s characters both shine incredibly when they meet their extended family for the first time. Bolin quickly learns the names of everybody and welcomes them all into his life. Mako, still reserved, finds comfort in meeting his grandmother for the first time. Their family was unaware of their parents’ passing, and when Mako has to break the news to their grandmother, he gives her his father’s scarf, which Mako has been wearing for the entirety of the show. Mako giving up the scarf to his father’s mother creates an unbelievably powerful moment shared by him, Bolin, and their family. That moment wouldn’t be possible without the long-term writing that has made the show so strong.

But whereas Bolin and Mako grow stronger for each other, we are also treated to another pair of siblings who prove that you don’t have to like each other to love each other. The Beifong sisters, Lin, and Suyin, act as parallels to many of the show’s other characters while still being compelling and powerful in their own right. The sisters are the daughters of the first metal bender, Toph Beifong, one of the protagonists in The Last Airbender, who has achieved legendary status within the Avatar World. Toph was blind and lived with an overbearing family that prevented her from living her own life until she ran away. As a parent, Toph chose to learn from her parents’ mistakes and gave her children incredible freedom, perhaps too much, with Suyin slipping into the life of a criminal and Lin going out of her way to become like her mother in an attempt to make her proud.

Lin has been around since the beginning of Korra and was originally used as another obstacle for Korra. As the chief of police, Lin was unwilling to let Korra run free in her city, finding the Avatar’s attitude and behavior to be frustrating and, at times, illegal. In time, however, Lin and Korra’s relationship grew into one of respect, and the two powerful women have been saving each other’s lives frequently ever since.

In season 3, we learn that, like Tenzin, Lin has never been able to get out of the shadow of her more famous parent. Suyin, who has since reformed and become a great leader of the Metal Clan, reveres her mother, continuing to build on her legacy since Toph has disappeared. Suyin does her best to convince Lin of her changed attitudes, but it takes much persuasion and an epic metal-bending fight to finally put the past in the past.

Lin and Suyin are able to move past their differences without ever acting as though their problems don’t exist. Like Bolin and Mako as they take on two of the Red Lotus members, Lin and Suyin work together, saving each other’s lives, to fight the incredibly powerful combustion bender of the Lotus.

Adding to all of these incredible characters is the series’ title star, Korra. Korra was always powerful, always skilled, and always sure of herself. Revered as a demigod since birth, Korra became abrasive, expecting everyone to listen to her and allow her to do as she pleased, leading to early season head-bumping with Tenzin and Lin. In season 2, her attitude almost sparked a civil war, but she came into her own as a leader by connecting to the Spirit World and gaining a greater understanding of the world in which she lives.

In season 3, however, Korra is pushed to the brink. Her decision to leave open the Spirit portals has proven very unpopular, and the people of the world don’t like how their world has been forever changed. Korra faces constant public scrutiny for her decisions, even leading to her banishment from Republic City.

Korra has also become the first Avatar since the original to be unable to speak with her past lives. For much of the show, when the Avatar reached rock bottom, Aang or Korra could call upon the spirits of their predecessors to offer guidance. With the opening of the Spirit portal, however, Korra’s connection has been severed. With the Avatar no longer acting as a bridge to the Spirit World, and without her connection to her past lives, in addition to the Equalists and the Red Lotus calling the Avatar a relic of a bygone era, Korra’s confidence in her ability and her importance to the world are thoroughly shaken. In overcoming the challenge of the Red Lotus, Korra was left broken, in a wheelchair, questioning if she is even needed anymore.

With Korra’s growth as a character, the stakes of the show have been raised. We are left with the idea that the world could really lose its Avatar as it modernizes into a society more familiar to us. The changing times may prove that the Avatar is no longer needed, and Korra could truly be the last. With that idea comes the possibility that The Legend of Korra’s title character will actually die, adding a new layer of interest to the show’s fourth and final season.

By the third season finale of The Legend of Korra, the audience is able to see the incredible depth of characters — and depth of character — that makes Korra so compelling. No fewer than nine heroes get to shine in the final battle, as four distinct and established villains fight them to the bitter end. Each fight carries with it greater emotional weight: we see the relationships between brothers, sisters, and fathers and their daughters. Even subtle moments carry the weight of history in them, such as the moment when Lord Zuko learns that Korra spoke with his uncle, which fans of The Last Airbender will remember was the most compelling relationship of that show.

The end of the season again establishes a new status quo as a Nation slowly rebuilds, a leader steps up, and another hits rock bottom. In an incredible move, the creators of The Legend of Korra have given us three straight epic seasons, full of action, adventure, drama, comedy, politics, philosophy, history, and rich characters. Without a doubt, The Legend of Korra will go down in history as one of the most unexpectedly great shows.

goodbye-11

As Doctors cycle through, so do fans’ emotions

“Everything’s got to end sometime; otherwise nothing would ever get started.”
“We’re all just stories in the end.”
The Doctor

In the spring of 2008, I finally took a coworker’s advice and began watching episodes of a British science fiction series some readers may have heard of called Doctor Who. I started from the beginning of the 2005 relaunch, which ended a 16-year drought of regular Doctor Who programming. I had no idea what I was getting myself into, and once I started watching the show, I didn’t understand how you could base a show around a single character, let the audience grow attached to that character, then change him just like that, as the show had done eight times already.

It didn’t take long for me to be completely hooked on the adventures of the Ninth Doctor and his companion, Rose. I would come home from work at 11 p.m. or later and not be able to go to sleep until I had watched at least one, most likely two, episodes. Christopher Eccleston was fantastic, and even though I knew he would only be in the first series (as those wacky Brits call “seasons”), I loved his portrayal of the Doctor and didn’t want to see him go. I was in tears by the end of the finale, “The Parting of the Ways.”

I had heard that Eccleston’s successor, David Tennant (whom I hadn’t yet connected to Harry Potter), was even more brilliant, but I didn’t see how that was possible. Tennant won me over by the end of “The Christmas Invasion,” the annual Christmas special (those Brits again) that served as the Tenth Doctor’s premiere. Once series 2 got underway with “New Earth,” I knew he would be my Doctor. It seemed as though he was born to play this role; he made being the Doctor seem so natural and effortless.

During Tennant’s time as the Doctor, we saw many companions come and go; losing Rose and Donna were the hardest for me. I had finally caught up to the American viewings on the Sci-Fi Channel (before its ridiculous name change) and was able to watch the series 4 finale with the rest of the United States (at least, with those who hadn’t downloaded and watched it already).

And then came the confirmation of news I thought I never wanted to hear: Tennant was leaving Doctor Who. First, I was in denial; then, I was heartbroken. He was my Doctor. He couldn’t leave. I couldn’t say goodbye.

I held off watching both parts of “The End of Time” for several weeks because I just wasn’t ready to accept that, by the end, the Tenth Doctor would be gone. And when I finally did watch, the Doctor’s farewell tour was just as difficult as I had imagined. His final words, “I don’t want to go,” echoed what a lot of fans were feeling in that moment.

And then suddenly, in a burst of light, he was gone; replaced by this strange, gangly guy who didn’t look nearly old enough to be the Doctor.

I loved Tennant so much in the role that I thought I would never be able to warm up to Matt Smith, but I’ve learned that there’s this funny thing that happens when you’re a fan of Doctor Who and a Doctor you love regenerates. In the beginning, there’s this feeling of trepidation and concern that the new actor won’t be up to performing the role as well as those who have gone before. You were so enamored with the previous Doctor that you really don’t want to see him go. Then, suddenly, one day you realize the Doctor hasn’t changed at all — at least not really. While his face is different and some aspects of his personality may seem new, he is still, deep down, the same Doctor he always has been. You really do love the new Doctor just as much as the old.

Smith kind of snuck up on me. It took me a little longer to warm to him than it did with Tennant (nearly two years longer), and I don’t even know when it was that I really started to love him. I just remember watching a repeat of Smith’s first Christmas special, “A Christmas Carol,” before his second, “The Doctor, the Widow and the Wardrobe,” aired and realizing that he really was an excellent Doctor. Tennant would always be my Doctor, but Smith now held a special place in my heart as well.

Even before I realized how much I loved his Doctor, Smith continually impressed me with how well he was able to capture the age of the Doctor; despite being the youngest actor to play the role, he really made you believe he was the oldest. He brought a lot of energy and charm to the role as well as a lot of depth and emotion. He introduced us to the Girl Who Waited, the Last Centurion, and the Impossible Girl — and let’s not forget Craig and Stormageddon, Dark Lord of All. He fought the Silence, Daleks, Cybermen, Weeping Angels, and so many more. He married River Song and saved her parents’ marriage. And he won over millions of fans every step of the way.

And now he’s gone.

Sure, he technically left back at Christmas, when we witnessed the Eleventh Doctor‘s regeneration into the Twelfth Doctor. But it didn’t seem real at that point. It would be months until I actually had to watch the new Doctor, so I could pretend for just a little while longer that Eleven was still having adventures with Clara in the TARDIS. However, when series 8 premieres in just over 48 hours, that delusion will be over, and I really will have to accept that Smith is no longer the Doctor.

The hardest part of being a fan of Doctor Who is knowing you will be saying goodbye to actors you love over and over again. But at the same time, this is also a unique and wonderful aspect of the show. While it’s heartbreaking to think that soon I’ll be watching a completely new Doctor, it’ll be exciting to see what Peter Capaldi brings to the role and in what ways he is different-from-yet-the-same-as the old Doctor.

As much as I hated seeing Smith go, I’m really looking forward to meeting Capaldi’s Doctor. I’m not quite as apprehensive as I was in the past; I think I’ve finally accepted that this is how the show works: a never-ending cycle of meeting new characters, accepting them, and loving them, then having to say goodbye. And it really does work; if any other show tried to completely reinvent itself every few years, it would fall apart, but Doctor Who has sustained the practice for more than 50 years.

On top of meeting a new Doctor as the next chapter opens Saturday, we’ll also be starting the process of saying goodbye to his current companion, Clara, as rumors began circulating earlier this week that the 2014 Christmas special will likely be her last episode. Saying goodbye is always hard, but we get to meet new people and the story continues, it doesn’t have to end just because one person’s time in the TARDIS is over.

I, for one, can’t wait to see how the journey continues Saturday night.

OUT-102_20131022_EM-0501.jpg

Outlander deviates, predictably, to show us skin

Read Curiata.com’s review of the series premiere of Outlander on Starz from last week: Outlander adapts time travel, intrigue to small screen


 

The second episode of Outlander, the television adaptation of Donna Gabaldon’s book series, aired Saturday on the U.S. premium network Starz. This installment is where conditions in 18th-century Scotland are vividly and accurately detailed. It opens with the arrival of Claire Beauchamp, who has been transported from the mid-20th century, at Castle Leoch. As Claire looks around her, she sees muddy streets, small crofts, animals milling about, people undertaking their primitive avocations in the courtyard, and traditional dress.

Mrs. Fitzgibbons is introduced to us as she bustles from the castle to greet the returning men. This character is cast perfectly. Annette Badland superbly captures Mrs. Fitz’s (as she is known about the castle) iron-fisted ability to manage a castle filled with unruly men, as well as her deep affection for those who are under her care. After her initial surprise of finding a barely-dressed Englishwoman upon her doorstep, Mrs. Fitz envelops Claire under her capable wing.

As Mrs. Fitz undertakes to feed and clothe Claire (“Let’s get you something that’s a bit more … well, more,” she deadpans), Claire resists, saying that the young man she had assisted earlier, Jamie MacTavish, needs tending because of his gunshot wound. Through a short inquiry, Mrs. Fitz learns that Claire is knowledgeable in medicine and knows what to do for an “inflamed wound,” which we would call an infection. Claire’s skill set definitely earns Mrs. Fitz’s respect, as healers and “charmers” are in short supply in a castle containing so many fighting men. Claire, with Jamie in tow, is taken to a room where garlic and witch hazel are provided her to use as a disinfectant. Mrs. Fitz, who also knows her way around an herb garden, brings cherry bark and comfrey to soothe the pain.

For the first time, Claire is alone with Jamie (whom she knows as Mr. MacTavish). As she removes Jamie’s plaid, she sees that his back is covered with scars. He explains that he was flogged by the English, once for escape and once for “obstruction,” which is “whatever the English say it is.” Claire also learns that Captain “Black Jack” Randall, her modern-day husband’s ancestor, is the one responsible for Jamie’s imprisonment and the floggings. Jamie shares stories about the English soldiers’ mistreatment of the Scottish people, describing an incident where Captain Randall presumably sexually assaulted Jamie’s sister, Janet “Jenny” (Laura Donnelly).

It is here that the show comes up short, losing sight of the book that inspired it. In the text, Janet is described as fine-boned and birdlike, which Donnelly capably represents. However, the written Janet is also fierce and defiant, especially toward the English. Unfortunately, none of this is conveyed on screen when Janet is manhandled by Captain Randall. Instead, the viewer is given several minutes of gratuitous nudity that could have been sacrificed for character development elsewhere. A flashback of the scene as it reads in the novel would have been sufficient to convey Randall’s brutality. In the end, Janet is portrayed as passive while the book showcased her strength of character in arguing with Jamie about whether she would or would not go with Randall in order to spare her brother.

Despite these missteps, the scene succeeds in creating a moment between Claire and Jamie. During their relatively intimate exchange, she tending his wounds and he sharing personal stories, Claire begins to think about her husband, Frank. Jamie comforts her as she cries (swoon!), and Claire is aware of an unbidden attraction to this strange man.

Before we know it, Mrs. Fitz is preparing Claire to meet the estate owner “Himself,” Colum Mackenzie (Gary Lewis), Laird of Castle Leoch and brother to Dougal, the battlefield leader whom Claire met earlier. These scenes wonderfully illustrate the standards of appropriate dress in the 18th century versus Claire’s own time in the 1940s. After being relieved of her own clothing (a simple dress and undergarments), Claire is forced into a shift, wool stockings and garters, stays (a corset), panniers, an under petticoat, an over petticoat, a kerchief to cover or enhance the bosom (whichever the case may be), a stomacher, and, finally, a gown.

Claire is escorted to Colum’s office, which features an impressive library and several exotic birds. A letter on the desk is dated “1 November 1743,” so it is now clear to Claire that she has, in fact, passed through time via the standing stone circle in Inverness. When Colum enters the office, Claire is shocked to see that he suffers from a significant deformity of his legs, which makes it difficult for him to walk.

Colum, while polite, prods Claire as to her family origins and how she came to be alone in the Highlands. Claire attempts to answer the questions as her husband Frank, an army spy, instructed her on how to withstand interrogation. (“Keep to the truth as much as possible.”) She requests passage back to Inverness, which Colum promises “with Mr. Petree, Saturday next.” (This plotline is not in the book.)

After her interrogation, Claire goes to a rooftop walkway and observes Dougal playing with a young boy who appears to be his son. This is a gross misunderstanding, as Claire discovers at dinner that night. The boy is not Dougal’s son, but his brother’s. Colum and his wife, Letitia (Aislin McGuckin), as well as the boy himself, are deeply offended by this mistake, and Claire excuses herself from the table, embarrassed. She is unable to make her escape, however, before being liberally plied with wine and further questioned by Colum. It is clear that the consensus in the castle is that Claire is an English spy who poses a threat to them all.

Claire spends much of her free time planning her escape and tending to Jamie’s wounds. Mrs. Fitz gives Claire the job of helping to gather medicinal and edible plants to supplement the castle’s cupboards. While foraging, Claire meets Geillis (pronounced Gay-liss) Duncan. Geillis (played by Lotte Verbeek) herself knows the many uses of herbs and makes it clear that she is very familiar with charms, poisons, and abortifacients. Witchcraft enters the conversation, a label that Geillis barely denies.

The two meet again that night in The Hall, which is a public forum where complaints are brought before Himself, who resolves them. When a young girl is accused by her father of “loose behavior,” Colum approves her punishment of a public lashing. At the last minute, though, young Jamie offers to take the girl’s punishment for her, in the form of being beaten with the fists of a fellow clansman, Angus. This, of course, requires Claire to tend to him once again.

Mrs. Fitz comes to thank Jamie for taking the punishment, and it is revealed that the young girl’s name is Laoghaire (pronounced Leh-heary), and she is Mrs. Fitz’s granddaughter.

Claire announces that she is leaving Leoch and instructs Jamie how to care for his own wounds. As they say their prim good-byes, Laoghaire peeks into the room, clearly wanting to see Jamie. Claire sends him off to her. The next day, as Claire is about to board the carriage that will take her to Inverness, she is summoned by Colum.

Colum shows Claire to the surgery of the Clan’s healers — the last one being Davey Beaton, deceased. He tells her that she will make a fine replacement. She protests and insists that she be allowed to return to Inverness, as promised. The episode ends as Colum tells Claire that she may not leave until he is satisfied that she has revealed her secrets and poses no threat to his Clan.

This second episode shines a light on a central element of the series. It slowly introduces the typical and expected behavior for 18th-century women: docile, obedient, and meek, with no opinions or thoughts of their own. Contrast those qualities with Claire, who is the exact opposite of this standard, drawing much unwanted attention and doing nothing to dispel rumors about her character.

The Outlander television series does well to retain those themes from the books. But the screen adaptation veers more from the books in this episode than it did in the premiere. It remains to be seen how far this deviation will go.

varrick

Korra draws parallels to real-world march to war

In a recent Nerd/Wise article, I defended the medium of animation as art on par with cinema and modern television dramas by pointing out the incredible social commentary in the first season of Legend of Korra. The program, however, was originally made to be a miniseries, and thus fit an entire story arc into only a dozen episodes, leaving out the filler that was more prevalent in its predecessor, Avatar: The Last Airbender.

Korra debuted as a big success, and Nickelodeon ordered three more seasons of the show. With over 40 new episodes to produce and no original plan to make any more than 12, the series creators had to get to work, leaving fans reasonably skeptical. But Bryan Konietzko and Michael Dante DiMartino did not disappoint with Korra’s second season and continued to showcase the narrative capacity of animated television.

How were they able to keep the show compelling? Konietzko and DiMartino created a season that expanded on the show’s spiritual aspects while grounding the narrative in a much more human story — the philosophical disputes and reasons that lead to war. And the on-screen machinations reflect real, historical precedents for the march to war.

Legend of Korra’s second season follows the protagonist as the society she knows begins to crumble around her. In the process, she becomes a participant in a dangerous process that almost leads her people into a civil war. The slippery slope begins, as they often do, with a supposed visionary pushing his beliefs on others, convinced he is on a spiritual crusade.

In the real world, when someone is so convinced he is on the one true path, he is often liable to take extreme measures to spread that supposed truth. We see this today, with the unrecognized Islamic State terrorizing Iraq and Greater Syria, as well as al-Qaida and other fundamentalist religious groups operating around the globe. Throughout history, we have seen these same attitudes manifesting in the Crusades, the Inquisition, and hundreds of other times when two distinct faiths have come into contact.

In Legend of Korra, it is Unalaq, Korra’s uncle, who believes the Southern Water Tribe has lost its spiritual way and seeks to rectify the situation. He shows Korra that the evolution and progress of humanity is actually harmful to its well-being, as their lack of spiritual understanding has led to a rising frequency of attacks from the Spirit World. After Unalaq saves Korra from an attack by a wayward spirit, the Avatar begins to trust Unalaq, at the expense of her own father, who suspects deception in his zealot brother.

Unalaq is the Chief of the Water Tribes, and his belief in the South’s spiritual failings leads him to take action. But Unalaq’s actions have consequences, and his attitudes inspire a rebellious attitude among the citizens of the South. Those citizens become convinced that independence is the only answer and begin their planning in secret meetings. In this way, the South’s actions mirror those of the American colonists in 1776, who grew tired of the British Parliament’s tightening grip.

The Sons of Liberty met in secret and began advocating for independence as the rest of the nation slowly became convinced. Troops occupying Massachusetts convinced most of the locals that action needed to be taken, and Parliament’s attempts to maintain control ironically caused them to lose it. Unalaq acts in much the same way, sending soldiers to occupy the South, raising tensions and marching his people closer to war. While Massachusetts delegate John Adams pushed the Continental Congress to declare independence, King George III made his intentions clear by sending in many more troops to quash the American rebellion. Adams was finally able to win over his colleagues by pointing out the obvious: that a state of war already existed between the colonies and their mother country.

The American Revolution tore families apart, and in Legend of Korra, the Avatar’s father and uncle find themselves on opposite sides of a conflict that promises to be destructive and deadly. When Unalaq’s intentions become clear, Korra decides to take action against her uncle and defend her father and people. Korra seeks out the help of a powerful nation to bring down the overbearing Unalaq and his troops.

During the American Revolution, it was Benjamin Franklin who sought a powerful nation, France, to help the struggling rebellion. Franklin used wit and his crafty personality to persuade King Louis XVI to send assistance to the Americans. Korra is a bit more direct — and characteristically abrasive — when asking the president of Republic City for help, and the president is unwilling to help out the independence seekers.

Without the help of the president, Korra tries realpolitik, going right to the Republic military with the request for help. Korra, as the spiritual center of the Avatar world, holds a lot of sway, and her brashness brings to light the problems with autocracy, whether within a theocracy or even a constitutional monarchy. If the decision to go to war lies in the hands of only one person, it could come about simply on a whim while a diplomatic solution is still viable. This is the reason the U.S. Constitution grants war-making powers to the legislative, and not the executive, branch of government.

Of course, in practice, that’s not the only way armed conflict actually takes shape in the United States. Spreading the war-making powers out among hundreds of people does not entirely tie the hands of the commander in chief and doesn’t mean senseless wars don’t happen. Especially not in a world in which war is profitable.

In trying to protect her people, Korra receives help from the character that perhaps best epitomizes American plutocracy in the entire show, Varrick. Varrick is the head of a large corporation with its hands in everything from manufacturing to media. Varrick uses his money to influence the politics of the world, funding the political campaigns of both Republic City presidential candidates, supporting the rebels in the South, and selling the weapons of war. Varrick is so blatant in his intentions that he makes Halliburton and Blackwater look like Girl Scouts, even outright saying, “If you can’t make money during war, then you just can’t make money.”

Varrick represents everything wrong with the current American military-industrial complex. Varrick is amoral, showing none of the traits we would normally associate with cartoon villainy, yet performing some of the most evil actions in the show. Varrick sees war as big business and will do what he has to in order to ensure fighting breaks out. He hires criminals to bomb public spaces to build support for the rebels, and sends them to rob Future Industries to force Asami to sell her company to him. Varrick then plans to profit even more off of the war by selling those same rebels Future Industries aircraft and robots.

Varrick even proves to be a master of propaganda. He enlists the help of Korra’s friend, Bolin, to star in “movers,” the Avatar world’s movies, which show Unalaq as a blatantly evil, Fu Manchu-like villain, ironically playing off the fact that the villains in the Avatar world are often colored with shades of gray. This, too, has its analog in world history.

During the World Wars, both sides of the conflict used movies to propagate their messages, often to a ridiculous degree. The Nazis disseminated their ideology with films such as Triumph of the Will and The Eternal Jew, while in America, Frank Capra released the film series Why We Fight to rally Americans behind the cause. Dr. Seuss was commissioned during the war to draw cartoons supporting the war effort, including some racist depictions of the Japanese, while Batman fought Asian stereotypes in film serials, and Superman made sure to “slap a Jap” in the comic books. Today, movies may not be as blatant in their propaganda, but using the media to spread a message — and even to start a war — is very much alive.

Legend of Korra, despite Nickelodeon’s decision to limit the show to digital distribution, continues to be an impressive work of fiction. The series manages to create a mythical epic while grounding it in an unfortunate part of the human experience. We may never be able to bend the elements, but we can relate to the feelings of helplessness as we watch the world around us descend into war. We can only hope that cooler heads ultimately prevail, but with so many factors constantly pushing the world toward conflict, that hope often seems misguided.